無名
觀眾影評
真係好鍾意呢套電影畫面表現，特別係其中唐部長企喺日本旗和青天白日旗中間，呢d咪叫做電影畫面語言，正~梁朝偉嘅國語對白好難得~有味道！王一博暗巷内暴打日本兵後扯自己條呔嗰下，真係有種變態暴力狂嘅感覺，唔錯唔錯！
對白好似蘊涵深意，我應該可能會再睇多次。
----------------
我今日又買咗飛睇多一場，冇辦法，琴日睇咗之後，心入面一路掛住掛住。
第二次睇，我又發現咗好多細節，原嚟嗰只廢墟中嘅小狗帶住果項圈嘅，咁佢嘅主人呢？佢主人應該地位唔低，但喺戰火下咪又系難以自保，好唏噓；然後喺廢棄工廠勞工中還有一個人拿着佛珠喺度祈禱，石矢傾瀉落下果個場景，嗰畫面又殘忍又有質感，我又唔忍心睇又忍唔住贊嘆構圖夠沖擊，佢下一個畫面就系一白色羊仔，導演喺度講畀我哋知當時嘅中国人就系待宰羔羊，好犀利吖導演。
睇完之後同frd喺度討論電影，傾傾下，我哋系咁講王一博，真系好靚仔，有幾個正面鏡頭有少少baby fat,系唔系00後？好有潛力吖，打人殺人嗰時有d殘忍有d邪惡還有少少變態嘅感覺，但喊起嚟又陰功又可愛，俾到驚喜吖，最後我frd問我，我哋唔系喺討論梁朝偉咩，點解一直講王一博，冇辦法喇實在系呢個靚仔太搶眼。
認真好睇，已經買左飛睇第二次
梁生的民國間諜片一向都有水準唔會伏。依個導演都幾特別，一開始打亂晒時間線，一時193x年一時194x年，每個片段畫面構圖好靚，但要睇到一半先知道各個片段劇情係互相影響，呢套戲只要能夠專心睇會發現好多細節。梁朝偉一如以往穩定，好多微表情做得好好，唔使對白都睇到佢情緒，周迅戲份唔多，但係角色好重要，而且演得好好，拒絕人地示愛嗰個「我有老公的」表情超嫌棄超搞笑，重有王一博，一開始我都諗呢個人點解可以poster度同梁生分一半位，睇完套戲之後我係服氣的，演得唔錯接得住影帝啲戲，打戲動作好靚好流暢。同梁生場肉搏真係睇到我好緊張！互相好似真係想殺咗對方咁，攞起身邊任何嘢來敲對方個頭又hum人地頭埋牆，嗰段真係好刺激。本身套戲成兩個幾鐘我原本驚會唔會好拖泥帶水拉長來講，但真係冇冷場值回票價。
Mum and dad really loved this movie which was not surprising given they are both huge fans of historical films. The pace was a tad slow at the start but the momentum picked up about 20 mins into the movie. The constantly shifting timeline means you've got to pay close attention to every little bit of detail but the pieces all fell into place at the end. All in all, a really enjoyable movie.
正！好良心既一部電影！台詞好正！打戲好搏！好耐無睇到d打到入肉既電影！偉仔一樣咁掂！王一博令人驚喜！想再睇既電影！
I watched this movie in Australia and I highly recommend it to the movie lovers. The filming, the mood, the music is just like an masterpiece. Tony Leung and Wang Yibo, both of them are great actors and they performed very well.It is hard to describe it in words. The Film is amazing.
無名帶給我極大驚喜，耳導用了倒敍插敍等手法，把一個簡明的故事搞成燒腦很懸疑，而且好重要係有很多留白，等觀眾睇完有唔同嘅諗法或者見解，一套討論度幾高吧片，演員全員有料到，新演員王一博也交到貨，同Tony哥嘅打戲文戲都唔核突，好片
Hidden Blade is a beautifully crafted Chinese movie that showcases exceptional film quality. The movie's puzzle-like timeline is both intriguing and satisfying, making it a standout feature.
The fighting scene between Tony Leung and Wang Yibo is breathtaking, and it's a testament to Tony Leung's acting skills that he still delivers intense performances in his 60s.
Wang Yibo's performance is stunning and captivating, leaving the viewer wanting more. Wang's potential as a young actor is also evident in this movie, and I'm excited to see what he does next.
Overall, Hidden Blade is a must-watch for anyone who appreciates exceptional filmmaking and impressive acting
我去看之前， 已经被所有平台剧透到几乎可以自主连接所有剧情了，但即便如此, 到最后一刹那叶先生说那句我已知的“我也是”的时候, 我还是猛击了大腿。这部电影节奏实在太好了，虽然为了大多数人能看懂，已经快把错位的东西手把手教学拼贴复原了，但还是极好看。
這部電影蠻看的呀！梁朝偉周迅演技很好啊！比較驚喜的王一博，這麼年輕，竟然演得這麼好，未來可期！
An awesome movie! A stylish masterpieces. The film is captivating and all the actors were all on the same pace and that takes a good director to do so. And finally the young Mr Yi who I assume was the hidden blade of the film, I can’t stop thinking of him not only his gorgeous face and the sadness of Mr Yi…. I will like to see more of him.
成部戲好似玩拼圖，一開始係有啲七零八落，但係就好似拼圖甘，連接位置都有多少重複影像關聯重疊，其實好容易就可以串聯到成個故仔，幾有意思。最後結尾個嘢真係好似無間道啊，睇到頭皮發麻！！！偉仔係拍過無間道類似場景，難道尼個就係緣分？！講真，偉仔成六十高齡同個後生仔仲可以打到甘衡，簡直想舉埋雙腳鼓掌。唔係飛黎飛去個種打，而真係拳腳功夫，睇到我差啲呼吸困難。王一博作為新人，可以同偉仔同埋周迅尼種層次嘅對手撐到個場，完全唔會出戲。留意到王一博面部微表情好有層次，文武廟流眼淚個下真係有令我眼濕濕，真係好心酸。王一博演技的確吾錯，真係後生可畏。尼幾年真係太少尼種有演技又靚仔嘅後生哥啦，打戲又好睇，掂吖！成部電影睇落嚟無咩bug，就係有啲食腦，一唔覺眼就會miss線索，好多小細節耐人尋味，翻屋企諗諗下又諗通一啲嘢。真係非常有意思。好多年無睇過甘好諗嘅電影啦。Good
好好睇！好精彩！最后翻转真系估佢唔到！王一博打戏真系好劲，后生仔生得又靓仔对白講得又好好聽！
第一印象係畫面好靚好震撼，畫質好正，服道化都超正。睇多少少原來係一幅大puzzle，但一啲都唔難明，仲令人更加留心睇，導演絕對係高手，成部戲冇冷場，亦冇多餘嘅角色或者對白。梁朝偉由阿飛正傳到依家真係越老越有味道，影帝就係影帝，演技真係揮灑自如，佢同周迅呢pair真係好match，可惜戲份少啲。後生嗰對真係樣眼，王一博演技估唔到咁好，拍埋影帝度一啲都唔遜色，好有層次，真係新一代男神，好耐冇咁年青又靚仔嘅男演員，香港影壇真係斷層得好嚴重。仲有後生呢輩真係應該睇下呢部戲，認識多啲自己國家嘅歷史。總括嚟講，睇一次唔多夠喉，過兩日會再睇多次。
王一博夠哂出位。
The plot is good, basically the whole process is high-burning, the picture is beautiful, and it is more visually amazing. Let me mention that the fighting scenes in it are very explosive! Wang Yibo's acting skills are really impressive! A good movie is worth watching several times!
套戲勁正, 好好睇呀, 梁朝偉演得好入神, 王一博又有型靚仔, 演技爆晒棚. 2個人既對打戲打到拳拳到肉, 入晒戲睇到個人好緊張呀! 無諗過王一博講日文都咁掂喎。同日本首領個場對手戲, 佢dup 低頭再望上嚟個陣勁有日劇feel, 浴室審判個場戲又係演技一流, 拍爛手掌! 成套戲既配樂都好有感覺, d 畫面好靚, 每一幕都好似poster一樣。真係一部好精彩既電影, 仲想睇多幾次!
前半段有d亂 可能因為本人吾了解呢方面既歴史啦 後半段開始漸入佳景 無乜冷場 都幾緊張刺激 演員表現吾錯 偉仔吾駛講 不過開始呈現老態了 周迅戲份吾多 無乜發揮 王一博外形吾錯 幾高大靚仔 最後好似係香港取景 突然之間覺得好有親切感
偉仔有型 一博靚仔 好睇
My boyfriend asked me to watch this movie. I was not interested at first but the movie completely convinced me. It is great! Leung Chiu Wai is amazing! Wang Yibo is also very good, even though he is a young actor, he acts very well, I thought he was the bad guy! I want to kick him for hurting my Tony.
Hidden Blade which has been honed for seven years (since The Wasted Times (2016))retains all the advantages of this director: elegant lens language, unique style, exploration of human nature,but never try to step in express his own emotion.
He think all the director's emotional explaination is losing of control. His move leave a lot of room for audience to feel, to think.It used ARRI ALEXA 65, the strongest camera on earth. Watch IMAX to see more detail of the masterly shoot scene.
Tony Leung is my favorite actor over 20 years, and Yibo, love this young star from Chinese Street Dance season 3.It's a wonderful treat to see them both in this movie. Surprisingly, Tony and Yibo in movie, not the ones i know before.When watch Hidden blade, only Mr. He and Mr. Ye there go through their tough time, shining their glories .
叶先生亦正亦邪
看第二次的無名
還是難掩心中的意難平
太多感想未能一一盡抒
在巨變的年代 有志長不得 有情留不住
多少名字被時代的洪流活埋 被帶進墳墓
片中最後的那陣風輕輕的把往事帶走了
舊人不再 世界回歸樸素
電影總是浪漫的
現實總是殘酷的
最後不得不讚電影在分鏡和畫面的處理, 還有程導對劇本台詞的斟酌，節錄下來都是金句。配樂方面也十分出色，令觀影者更能融入劇情，無論是舞廳/走進主任辦公室內的西式弦樂合奏、或是和歌把酒都映襯出一片淡淡的哀傷無奈，期待將來會有無名的電影原聲帶推出。
好好看 This film is so amazing!! Now i can understand the reason why people told that this film must be watched twice or even more....
A superb masterpiece entailing the matrix of nostalgia and bitterness towards the darkest era of contemporary chinese history. Every scene in this movie pic has inspirational and profound meaning which reflects the director's view of life and the world outlook. Bits and thats of clues were weaved in a clever way. Some may categorize it as a cult movie yet I think the atmosphere achieved is remarkable.
The plot is intriguing with a number of reversals. The charm of spy game and suspense really surpasses Er's previous movies. Not to mention the marvelous casting and performance from Tony and Yibo.
My conclusion is go watch it if you like movie with great artistic brush and depth. Don't let the views of antis and the malicious dictate to you what you should or shouldn't do. They are not your brains. So enjoy and no prejudice.
無名係近年難得一見嘅良心好戲，劇情夠緊湊，環環相扣，底牌掀開嘅時候真係爽到爆！梁生好穩陣，普通話有驚喜，王一博好貴靚仔，打鬥戲打得好好睇！
很好的电影 很好的表演
雖然整部片是非線性敘事，但許多場景導演重複讓它出現，像是你在考試，老師給了你很多提示。第一次出現會稍微不懂，但後續又再提起一次，並加入更多傳達的信息，很有趣的一部電影。
周迅跟梁朝偉擁抱那裡，臉部表情處理得超級好，肌肉顫抖還有情緒超讚的！！！
“我不同意你卸下這身軍裝”這句話展現出債必有償，總不能說犯下那麼多罪，拍拍屁股走人回去當農夫安老，當你舉起那把屠刀開始，你終將死於刀下。
初見耳導 22歲 羅曼蒂克消亡史相識
初見一博 25歲 小藍相識
今年因為一博再次見到熟嘅導演，克制嘅鏡頭語言太稀有。
與耳導片初見，於22歲，與一位男生走進影院，一眾片度見到羅曼嘅封面，絕美暗色鮮艷嘅一抹紅色裝住我目光。 但好對唔住，我冇睇明，不過都共情到戰亂時代活著的希望。 嗰個女仔真系好易讓我感動。 業界男生已經瞓著。 自己觀影習慣，即使睇唔明，唔瞭解，都會慢慢去探索導演畀個鏡頭語言去瞭解故仔。
無名比羅曼更直白，第一遍觀影，我的體感完全麻木，甚至不敢共情，廣州一年多的轟炸，板車上的屍體，周圍的廢墟，敵人倒數到小朋友，被打斷說井里髒東西，下一秒就是一群人仰視希望卻是末日的倒計時，被葉秘暗殺的那個人拖走背後惡狗的喚叫，徬佛下一秒人就放進去讓他們撕咬。
我刷了三遍，每次出影院都能感受那種支離破碎，今朝不知何夕有的恐懼感。太深刻了
無名不是單純的影片，是一段訴說的歷史，是另一種角度觀察著，殘酷的情報局里暗湧流動視角的歷史，沒人誰願意使用多層身份去活著，在敵人的眼皮底下傳遞情報，當下是有無名者幸存的，年少時就開始拯救支離破碎的國家。
看了很多觀影者觀影感，發現了很多暮年的先生女士們去觀影，這部無名說的也是他們的過去。希望我們現在更珍惜當下的平安歲月。
不是從一位年輕小生追隨者的角度去觀看影片。
樂聲起，放下雜念，真正沈浸在導演訴說的歷史里去回顧往日曆史的課程。
這種克制的鏡頭語言太稀有。
It's been a long time since I've seen such a good movie. Tony Leung is amazing. The plot is full of surprises. Cheng Er's shooting style is unique. I like his footage. Very perfect.
Hidden Blade is a a wonderful movie...Great combination of director Er Cheng n the cast..especially the main characters Tony Leung n Yibo Wang...Tony is one of my fav actors...but to my surprise...the young actor Yibo's performance is amazing n impressive as well..Hidden Blade is a great movie n highly recommend ...im sure u wont got disappointed!!
攞走粉絲濾鏡，單憑看文藝文心情入場，沒有任何大期望之下，驚喜連連。
之前看過國內一些影評說剪接碎濕濕，混亂難明，但相比起Hollywood 一些更加難明的大片，無名可以說是非常簡單，連沒有太多對這時期背景認識的我也覺得不難明白。
拍攝唯美但不過份，對白算多但不沈悶，現場收音普通話日文廣東話上海話絕對係誠意。當然梁生廣普很明顯但不影響發揮，王甜甜－如過往又奶又兇。但最令人驚喜是演技比過往任何一部劇集劇集都進步太多，尤其浴室殺日本人及卡車挑釁挑釁梁生兩場戲都非常出色！導演帶得好之餘亦顯得下過工夫，尤其上海話日語能說得那麽流利簡直－讚！
人生1st影評，無名畀我2個驚艷，3個佩服。一佩服程耳導演對唯美鏡頭、音效、獨特敍事風格嘅堅持；二佩服入行40多年嘅偉仔打戲仍親自落場，拳拳到肉，單係哩場打戲已值回票價；三佩服周迅，鏡頭不多，但讓人印象深刻。其實，裏面每一個演員都好出色，讓我驚艷嘅係江疏影同王一博，江演嘅女特務有一種難以言喻嘅蒼涼美艷，王演嘅葉先生讓我打開眼界，原來暗黑西裝友係好好好有魅力嘅，以後王一博嘅作品我都會捧場嘅。
首日上映睇左一場，後勁有D大，想來想去，當晚攞紙筆砌了一下故事各片段嘅時間線，導演哩種敍事手法我覺得好有趣。下周約朋友再去睇多場，聽講，睇過一次會開天眼，有上帝視角，睇第二round會更爽呢～
很好看！！每個畫面都非常靚而且有質感，打戲又真實刺激 拳拳到肉 故事有反轉 有感人既情節 。電影本身有好多比喻 需要用心觀看 ！唔係一部冇腦得啖笑嘅電影！！
梁朝偉周迅演技非常之好！！新人王一博年紀輕輕可以同梁朝偉佢哋比美了！而且而且非常靚仔！！非常之多經典嘅鏡頭 卡車 浴室 等等……
睇到其他人話程耳堪比王家衛就入場觀摩一下，但其實唔太王家衛，可算各有千秋，程導演既畫面真係好靚，美指應記一功。
開始時覺得剪接零碎，但後面佢一直俾返0的碎片你砌埋佢，砌出黎時竟然有種淡淡既快感....睇依套戲要有0的耐性，前一個鐘都唔係爽片，你當一半文藝一半爽片睇就好OＫ，兩者唔沖突。
同埋鐘意佢唔會硬塞你日本人係衰中國人好慘既觀念，由得你自己感受，係最後有少少畫公仔畫出腸既問題，但可能怕大家睇唔明啦，無法，做導演都要衡量大眾接受力，明既。
梁朝偉而家揀得黎接既戲總會有Ｄ野，果不其然，風格一流，第一次睇卧底片會用大量對白黎營造劍拔弩張感，鐘意佢用大量食飯戲，用應該最輕鬆既場景去表達各位你虞我詐既情勢。
佢第一場同張先生既戲，一場戲入面三個情緒，轉換自如，影帝不愧係影帝，佩服！
周迅又係超好戲，戲份唔多但一場就夠話你知佢有幾愛佢老公，厲害。
第二男主角王一博出乎意料地擔得起個角色，依0的奸仔角，經驗不足既演員會好容易就好用力去演，話你知佢係奸既，但佢完全無，好似出自內心地奸同冷血，0係車度挑釁偉仔0個場，我同朋友睇完都話佢0個野真係好打靶仔，haha!!
然後佢日文同上海話好似都講得幾好?至少日文D語氣都幾到位，尤其５人飯局度，佢對日本上司點頭0個野，好靚！唔係經典五官但就係覺得佢好靚，後面監獄殺人0個度，根本就係場獨腳戲，竟然一人可以撐起成場氣氛。
最後幾場喊戲都好到肉，知佢未婚妻慘死時傷心到透唔到氣依下好真實！係好入戲既表現黎！同偉仔互毆時都好狠，竟然唔留手哈哈哈哈哈!! btw ，可能身形問題？佢打架打得超好睇，打得兩場唔夠喉啦 >A< !
Google左野原來王一博得25歲，希望之後佢有更多電影拍啦。大陸好似好耐無出過又後生又識做戲仲要靚仔既明星喇。
然後決定去搵程耳既電影睇下先~
這部電影還不錯，情節很有趣，演員們很好地刻畫了角色。梁朝偉和王一博的打斗場面十分激烈。王一博在貨車上跪在佛堂的畫面，真是讓人嘆為觀止。內心的動盪，痛苦，失去一切，朋友，同志，親人。過著匿名的生活，無法告訴我信任的人我在做什麼，在我自己的生活中感到孤獨。向無名英雄致敬。值得一看的電影。
出乎意料好睇，有劇情有藝術感的高質素電影！
畫面拍攝鏡頭好靚，剪接編排特別，劇情唔難理解，無名小人物大成就。
每個演員演技好到位，眼神面部細節表情一絕。
未睇過程耳導演的戲...只為梁朝偉.王一博而來..電影無論是燈光..服装..場景甚至道具都一絲不苟...每位角色都恰如其分..好有記憶點..連動物都好好戲 ahh...梁朝偉不愧是影帝...演技超班之餘..全程仲以普通話原聲上場...非常有誠意...至於跳舞出色..著上西裝嘅王一博...好型仔 ahhh ,(我有追佢嘅 "這就是街舞" .佢係戲中嘅普通話.上海話.同日文都咁好掂...明顯下過苦功...他同梁生嘅打戲尤其精彩..好逼真 ahhh.. 睇得好肉紧！！我估梁朝偉係第一次拍戲係咁打法.. 而令我最有深刻印象嘅係王一博係浴室殺日本仔果埸戲..無論係表情.肢體語言同日語對白..都好正...仲有以為完場時嘅另一段戲 ~ "我也是" .....最後記得要聽埋首主題曲先至好走 ahhh. 係戲院音响效果下聽..好有 feel.. 呢出戲係我近期睇過最好嘅..一定唔會令你失望！！！
垃圾之中既垃圾。
睇左30分鐘就想走, 不過同朋友睇, 費事走, 但見有2個人走左, 冇番黎。
1. 唔自然, 完全投入唔到: 戰爭片, 但軍人D衫又新, 又乾淨, 完全唔似打仗中。個個時期既中國間諜好有錢架咩? 個個人D衫都好靚, 乾淨, 全新既, 又多靚衫換, 梁換左好多套, 但睇佢又唔似係有錢人背景。被拘留中既女人, 話自己被人用刑, 但個妝容完美, 個髮型set到好靚, 件衫更靚。極度唔符合情理, 作為觀眾真係完全投入唔到, 實在太假。D車又靚, 又係全新既。。。其他野都有古典既味道, 但睇清楚就見到都係新架。全部野都係硬堆砌出來。
2. 冇邏輯: 呢個會嚴重劇透就唔講了。總然言之, 就係個結果完全冇邏輯，為反轉而反轉。其中一幕, 趕住走路, 但仲可以慢慢帶耳環。
悶到爆!
由頭悶到尾!